Cheese Profile

What Is Brick Cheese? Should You Buy It Young or Aged?

Choose young Brick for melting or aged Brick for a stronger bite. Explore Detroit pizza edges, rind, pairings, nutrition, milk labels and pregnancy precautions.

Pale block of Brick cheese with slices and pickles - Brick Cheese | KnowTheCheese
BRICK CHEESE QUICK FACTS
OriginWisconsin, United States, first made in 1877
MilkCow's milk, listed as pasteurized, and the federal standard also allows unpasteurized milk if the cheese is cured at not less than 35°F for at least 60 days
TextureSemi-hard (Cheese.com) or medium-soft (Wikipedia)
RindWashed, smear-ripened
AgingConsidered ready after two weeks, can stay in cold storage for up to five months (Wikipedia)
Fat Content29.7 g per 100 g in USDA reference data
FlavorDescribed as mild and sweet young, pungent and tangy aged
PregnancyNHS permits pasteurised Brick, while raw or unclear milk needs thorough cooking until steaming hot. US: raw or unlabelled Brick has no CDC safer route even cooked, cold medium-soft Brick sits in neither CDC column, and heat soft or deli-sliced pieces to 165°F or steaming hot.
Young Brick is suggested for melting, macaroni and platters, aged Brick for rye, pub mustard and full-flavoured beers

Choose young Brick for melting and aged Brick for a pungent, tangy bite. This Wisconsin cow's-milk cheese ranges from mild and sweet to stronger-smelling and nutty as it matures, so the age matters when buying for pizza or the table.

Young, unaged Brick is suitable for melting and suits macaroni, potatoes au gratin and platters. For an aged piece, think rye or crusty bread with pub mustard.

Pick young, aged or a flavoured product

The descriptions agree on mildness when young, but use different texture labels and describe the older flavour differently:

How Brick's texture and flavour are described
Question Answer
Texture Semi-hard, open and smooth (Cheese.com), medium-soft, softer than Cheddar (English Wikipedia)
Young Brick Mild in all three, mild and sweet (Cheese.com), mild with a touch of nuttiness (Wisconsin Cheese), sweet and mild (English Wikipedia)
Aged Brick Pungent and tangy with a touch of nuttiness (Cheese.com), more complex, pungent and tangy (Wisconsin Cheese), stronger smell and a nuttier taste (English Wikipedia)

Read those as separate accounts rather than a guarantee of one texture at every age. “Aged” alone is not an exact maturity: ask how long the block was kept.

Brick is considered ready after two weeks and may remain in cold storage for up to five months in Wikipedia's account. Follow your pack's storage and use-by instructions alongside the seller's age information.

Widmer's sells mild Brick, aged Brick, caraway-and-jalapeño Brick and an aged spread combining washed-rind Brick with aged white cheddar. The plain cheese's young-to-aged descriptions do not describe those added flavours or the spread's blend.

Joe Widmer is a Wisconsin Master Cheesemaker for Brick, cheddar and colby. It is a title from a three-year program for cheesemakers with at least ten years making their chosen cheese.

Use young Brick for Detroit-style pizza edges

Brick is called the traditional cheese for Detroit-style pizza, with cheese spread right to the edges: Wisconsin Brick or mozzarella. It caramelizes against a high-sided, heavyweight rectangular pan, creating the lacy, crisp rim of the pizza.

The style dates to 1946 at Buddy's Rendezvous in Detroit, owned by Gus and Anna Guerra. The Takeout's Dennis Lee describes Brick as mild, white, fatty and creamy, and calls it an ideal melting cheese.

The edge forms when cheese melts between crust and pan. Loui's Pizza puts the pepperoni down first, adds almost a pound of Brick and bakes at 700°F (370°C).

Brick can withstand that heat because of its butterfat content. Shield's Pizza instead bakes for thirteen minutes at 440°F (225°C), so those are distinct pizzeria methods.

The buttery crust flavour is credited to a small quantity of oil and the melting properties of mozzarella and Wisconsin Brick. The crisp edge is called frico.

Sauce goes on top to prevent a soggy crust and keep the cheese anchored to the rim, in The Detroit News explanation reproduced in the pizza account.

Detroit-style pan pizza with cheese caramelized into a crisp edge against the pan walls - Brick Cheese | KnowTheCheese
Illustration of a Detroit-style pizza with the cheese caramelized against the pan walls, as Wikipedia describes the style.
IF YOU CANNOT FIND BRICK

Outside Detroit and Wisconsin, The Takeout describes Brick as difficult to find in ordinary grocery stores and often sourced directly from Wisconsin. Its alternative is low-moisture mozzarella, which resembles Brick enough to make savoury cheese edges, and Detroit-style chain Jet's Pizza uses mozzarella.

Build plates and pairings around the age

Wisconsin Cheese puts young Brick on a meat and cheese platter, in macaroni and potatoes au gratin, and slices it for sandwiches or melts it with polenta. For mature Brick, its plate is rye, spicy pub mustard and sautéed onion.

Widmer's suggests a slice of its aged Brick on crusty bread with stone-ground or spicy pub mustard. Pickled vegetables and toasted Italian bread are further accompaniments in the cheese reference.

PairingTypeWhy It Works
Macaroni and potatoes au gratinFoodWisconsin Cheese suggests them for young Brick, and Cheese.com names both for Brick.
Rye, pub mustard and sautéed onionFoodWisconsin Cheese suggests them for mature Brick.
Crusty bread and stone ground mustardFoodWidmer's pick for its aged Brick.
Pickled vegetables and toasted Italian breadFoodCheese.com, for Brick.
Light red wine, Gamay BeaujolaisWineCheese.com, for young Brick.
Porter ale and full-flavoured beersDrinkCheese.com, for aged Brick.

Cheese.com adds hard cider for aged Brick. Its young-cheese suggestion is light red Gamay Beaujolais with sweet pickles, and its aged suggestions include porter and stronger beers.

Beer and wine options by source

For beer, bock, pale ale, porter and stout overlap between Wisconsin Cheese's list for Brick and Widmer's, which wants a substantial partner. The former also includes weiss beer and brown ale.

For wine, the overlapping choices are Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, Riesling, Sauvignon Blanc and Grüner Veltliner. Widmer's adds Merlot, Champagne, Beaujolais and Pinot Gris.

Porter appears across all three pairing accounts, while Beaujolais overlaps between Widmer's and the reference's young-Brick suggestion. Leftover Brick also goes into beer-cheese dip in Dennis Lee's recommendation.

Aged Brick cheese with rye bread pickles mustard and amber beer - Brick Cheese | KnowTheCheese
Illustration of aged Brick with rye bread, mustard and beer, which Wisconsin Cheese, Widmer's and Cheese.com pair with aged Brick. Cheese.com names pickles for Brick.

The bricks, Cheddar lineage and washed rind

It is named for bricks: most accounts describe weights pressing moisture or whey from curd, while another describes how actual bricks originally formed the brick shape. John Jossi made the first Brick in 1877, or around 1877 in the cheese reference.

Founded in Theresa, Wisconsin in 1922, Widmer's Cheese Cellars still presses its curd with actual bricks. Its hand-filled moulds turn three times on the first day while the bricks weight the curd and remove whey.

The maker uses the recipe, open vats and clay-fired bricks of Joe Widmer's grandfather and calls itself one of the few makers that still produce the original version.

Pale cheese curd in white molds with a red clay brick resting on top of each - Brick Cheese | KnowTheCheese
Illustration of curd in molds weighted with bricks, the pressing step Widmer's Cheese Cellars describes for its Brick.

Why the paste and rind invite different comparisons

The make traces to white American Cheddar, while rind and aroma invite the Limburger comparison. In Wikipedia's account, slightly higher culturing temperature gives marginally higher fat, a slightly altered protein structure and a slightly softer texture.

Cheese.com describes the result as slightly soft with a distinctly sharper taste. Wisconsin Cheese describes German immigrants treating it as a less pungent Limburger alternative and summarises the taste as somewhat softer with a sharper finish.

Widmer's uses lower levels of Brevibacterium linens rubbed on the rind, describing a tamer, milder Limburger relation. Germany's surface-ripened Beer cheese, or Bierkäse, is another German relative beside Limburger that many people associate with Brick.

Salt, warm ripening and surface cultures

Traditional Brick is brined, rested warm to encourage flavour-producing bacteria and hand-washed in brine. Widmer's follows the same order: a brine bath introduces salt and cultures, then comes the warm-room rest and brine washing.

Other accounts specify a mix of water and whey for washing. The named surface bacteria also differ: Brevibacterium linens, shared with Limburger and many French cheeses, or Corynebacterium and Arthrobacter bacteria.

Both use “smear” for the growth, giving the smear-ripened classification. The colour descriptions are pale yellow to white with an orange rind or ivory or creamy yellow.

What the US standard requires, and what the label leaves open

21 CFR 133.108 sets Brick's federal standard of identity. These are its composition and make requirements:

  • Milkfat is at least 50% of the solids by weight, while moisture is at most 44% of the cheese.
  • Milk is pasteurised, or the cheese is cured at 35°F or above for at least sixty days.
  • Culture is added at about 88°F, with stirring and slow heating to about 96°F.
  • Optional ingredients include colouring, clotting enzymes, antimycotic agents and calcium chloride up to 0.02%.

After the enzyme sets the milk, the mass is cut into roughly ⅜-inch cubes and stirred during heating towards 96°F. Once firm, some whey is removed and water or salt brine dilutes the mixture to control acidity.

The curd drains in forms, is pressed and turned, then salted after drainage. Surface cultures characteristic of Brick are applied before curing.

The standard also permits another procedure yielding the same physical and chemical properties. The reference's objection is that its fat and moisture limits do not account for the surface ripening with B. linens expected of Brick.

For vegetarian needs, obtain the maker's enzyme origin: the reference marks Brick not vegetarian, and the standard permits rennet or other clotting enzymes. Animal, plant and microbial enzymes may all be declared simply as “enzymes”, so that word alone cannot identify the origin.

Read nutrition values for the actual portion

USDA reference data republished by NutritionValue.org gives the following per 100 g:

Calories371
Protein23.2 g
Fat29.7 g, of which 18.8 g saturated
Carbohydrate2.8 g, of which 0.5 g sugars
Calcium674 mg
Sodium560 mg
Water41.1 g

The water figure, 41.1 g, sits below the 44% moisture ceiling. Fat is 29.7 g of the remaining 58.9 g solids, about 50.4%, just above the standard's 50% minimum.

The same record's 28 g slice has 105 calories, 8.4 g fat, 5.3 g saturated fat and 159 mg sodium. Total sugars are 0.5 g per 100 g, so use your exact product's panel when managing lactose intolerance.

Pregnancy: verify the milk and serving method

The cheese reference lists Brick as pasteurized cow's milk, but the federal standard allows raw milk cured for sixty days or more at 35°F or above. That legal maturation condition is not a pregnancy safety clearance.

A labelled pasteurised Brick fits the NHS safe list under its semi-hard or medium-soft descriptions. If the label is raw or unclear, cook thoroughly until steaming hot.

The CDC rates raw-milk dairy riskier. In the US, raw or unlabelled Brick has no CDC safer route even cooked, and a pasteurised medium-soft piece eaten cold sits in neither CDC column.

For a soft or deli-sliced piece in the US, heat to 165°F or until steaming hot: the CDC also puts unheated deli-sliced cheese in its riskier column. Pasteurisation does not remove that deli-sliced action.

With Brick's variable milk and texture, remember the CDC pregnancy comparison: “10 times more likely to get a Listeria infection”. Read the broader cheese in pregnancy guidance before treating one cheese description as universal permission.

CHECK THE LABEL
NHS permits pasteurised Brick, but thoroughly cook raw or unclear milk until steaming hot. US: cold medium-soft Brick sits in neither CDC column, raw or unlabelled Brick has no safer route even cooked, and heat soft or deli-sliced pieces to 165°F or steaming hot.

SOURCES & REFERENCES


1.
Wisconsin Cheese Reference
John Jossi 1877, bricks pressing the curds, German immigrants and Limburger, brining and hand washing, young and aged flavour, wash liquid, food, beer and wine pairings.

2.
Wisconsin Cheese Reference
Theresa 1922, 360,000 pounds a year, open vats and clay-fired bricks, hand moulding, curd pressed with actual bricks, brine bath and washing, lower Brevibacterium linens than Limburger, mild, aged, flavored and spread forms, Master Cheesemaker title, beer and wine pairings.

3.
Cheese.com Cheese Reference
Wisconsin origin, John Jossi around 1877, pasteurized cow's milk, semi-hard smear-ripened, washed rind, ivory, flavour change with age, not vegetarian, food and drink pairings.

4.
English Wikipedia Reference
1877, brick-shaped form, Cheddar lineage and culturing temperature, medium-soft texture, colour and orange rind, ready after two weeks, up to five months, Brevibacterium linens smear, whey-and-water wash, melting when unaged, standard of identity and surface ripening, Detroit-style pizza.

5.
US Code of Federal Regulations (Cornell LII) Gov
50% milkfat of solids, 44% moisture, 60 days at 35F if unpasteurized, 88F and 96F make temperatures, ⅜ inch cubes, dilution with water or brine, salting after drainage, optional ingredients, label declaration of enzymes.

6.
English Wikipedia Reference
Brick or mozzarella to the edges, caramelized lacy edge called frico, butterfat and heat, buttery crust flavor, Buddy's Rendezvous 1946, Loui's Pizza 700F, Shield's Pizza 440F, sauce on top.

7.
Dennis Lee, The Takeout Trade News
Mild white cheese with plenty of fat, resembles mozzarella, how the edge forms, availability, sold in the deli case, low-moisture mozzarella substitute, Jet's Pizza, beer cheese dip.

8.
NutritionValue.org (USDA reference data) Reference
Calories, protein, fat, carbohydrate, sugars, calcium, sodium and water per 100 g, and the 28 g slice.

9.
NHS Gov
The NHS lists of cheese and dairy foods that are safe to eat, to be careful with, or to avoid in pregnancy.

10.
CDC Gov
The CDC's table of riskier and safer food choices for pregnant women, including its cheese rows.