Choose Blacksticks Blue for a soft, creamy orange paste with a gentle blue tang. It comes from Butlers Farmhouse Cheeses' family Lancashire dairy, and the Great Taste judges in 2023 called it an introductory choice for someone new to blue cheese.
In This Article
Annatto colours the paste. Blue veins add the tang
The orange comes from annatto, made from achiote seeds, with a subtle flavour contribution in the account from Butlers. The ingredient description in Bowes Dairy's listing is “Full Fat Coloured Blue Veined Cow's Milk Cheese, Colour (Annatto).”
Expect a golden-orange colour, as in the description from Great British Chefs, crossed by blue veins. The 2023 judges noted a rustic farmhouse appearance and evenly distributed blue.

The blue intensity sits towards the back of the flavour in the description from Butlers. A mild bite and creamy paste make it a different cooking choice from a more forceful blue.
| Source | Flavour or texture |
|---|---|
| Butlers Farmhouse Cheeses | Not a harsh blue flavour, quite mild, with an intensity you can taste at the back |
| Great Taste judges (2023) | A "surprising amount of buttery rich flavour and melt in the mouth-feel," with a blue that is "very light and adds a mild tang" |
| Great British Chefs | Mild and creamy, with a salty tang |
| Bowes Dairy (retailer) | Soft, buttery texture with a subtle blue bite |
| Cheese.com | Soft, creamy and spreadable, creamy and tangy |
The soft, creamy and spreadable texture in Cheese.com sits alongside the judges' buttery, melting mouthfeel and moderate salt. For cooking, the recommendation from Great British Chefs favours it over stronger blues such as Stilton when you want complexity without a bitter tang dominating.
Local milk, a 2003 creation and a 2004 launch
The range introduced Blacksticks in 2004 as a contemporary addition to British cheesemaking. It is made by traditional handmade methods from milk collected each morning from herds within 10 km of the dairy and pasteurized on site before going into the vats.
In a 2023 Lancs Live visit to the dairy, the creation date is 2003, a year before that introduction date. Chefs including Nigel Haworth and Simon Rimmer had wanted local versions of the continental-style cheeses they encountered abroad.
That report records the orange Lancashire blue as an unusual idea for its time. The family has farmed Wilson Fields Farm in Inglewhite, near Preston, since 1932.
Its older Sunday Best Lancashire dates to 1969, takes 48 hours to make and matures for 18 months. Fourth-generation brothers Matthew and Daniel Hall run sales and cheesemaking respectively.
The farmhouse account links the milk to the family herd and the grass growth to high rainfall between Preston and Lancaster. The cheese is listed as vegetarian, and its edible rind contributes flavour.
Pick a wedge, burger rounds or a whole cheese
| Format | Size | Use and form |
|---|---|---|
| Wedge | 150 g | The standard pack, with ingredients, nutrition and vegetarian status listed |
| Whole baby truckle | Not stated | Listed on the range page |
| Mega Melts | 4 rounds, 160 g | Thick-cut rounds with edible rind for burgers and grilled sandwiches |
| Whole cheese | 2.5 kg | About 21 cm across and 7 cm high |
The baby truckle has no stated weight in this range listing. A separate 500 g Mature Your Own version develops its blue veins after purchase, so follow that product's instructions rather than treating it as a standard ready-to-eat wedge.
For nutrition, the wedge and whole-cheese panels match, while Mega Melts differs in five figures. Milk is the only allergen listed for the wedge.
| Per 100 g | Wedge and whole cheese | Mega Melts |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | 1620 kJ / 391 kcal | 1643 kJ / 397 kcal |
| Fat | 33.5 g | 33.5 g |
| Saturates | 21.0 g | 22.2 g |
| Carbohydrate | 0.1 g | 2.4 g |
| Protein | 22.3 g | 21.1 g |
| Salt | 2.0 g | 1.25 g |
A 30 g portion of the wedge gives about 117 kcal and 0.6 g salt, calculated from the per-100 g panel. Compare the correct format's label when checking a slice or a burger round.
Melt it into a meal or use a burger round
For everyday cooking, the suggestions from Butlers include toasties, jacket potatoes, beans on toast and pasta dishes. It grates, slices and melts, and the maker's interview favours beef and chicken more than fish.

Mega Melts rounds fit topping burgers, vegetarian burgers and grilled sandwiches. Put them under a hot grill for a couple of minutes or close the barbecue lid to heat around the slice, but that short cooking suggestion is not a pregnancy through-heating guarantee.
The meal ideas in Butlers' blog use the cheese stirred in, crumbled or as a topping:
- Nachos: use it on nachos with salsa, with guacamole and jalapeños.
- Cheese straws: combine with puff pastry, about 20 minutes overall.
- Blue sauce: melt with cream, butter and seasonings.
- Mac and cheese: crumble into the bechamel for mac and cheese or scatter over the top.
- Pizza: add to a pizza before baking.
- Bolognese: stir in a little while cooking for a tangy finish.
Other options are soups made with broccoli, parsnip, cauliflower, potato or mushroom, salads or a melted topping for steak.
Contrast the creamy paste with sweet, sharp or bitter food
For a cheeseboard or sandwich, the pairing idea from Butlers is a sweet or sharp contrast. Blackberries, bitter chicory leaves and crunchy radishes give you different ways to build that contrast.
| Pairing | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| Sweet flavours | A contrast to the creamy blue paste. |
| Sharp flavours | A sharper contrast to the creamy paste. |
| Blackberries | A suggested accompaniment. |
| Bitter chicory leaves | A suggested accompaniment. |
| Crunchy radishes | A suggested accompaniment. |
| Beef and steak | The salty tang suits beef without a stronger blue flavour taking over. |

Pregnancy: treat it as a soft blue even though pasteurised
The NHS wants soft blues such as Danish blue thoroughly cooked in pregnancy. As with Danish blue, heat Blacksticks Blue all the way through until steaming hot, as its pasteurised milk and edible rind do not remove the soft-blue precaution.
For US guidance, the CDC rates pasteurized soft cheese safer heated to 165°F or until steaming hot. A cold piece is outside that line, and a melted surface alone does not show that the whole piece reached it.
That distinction matters in pregnancy, when Listeria infection is 10 times more likely. The handling decisions for soft blue cheese in pregnancy apply regardless of how mild the cheese tastes.
Cover and refrigerate the opened pack
The pack-specific estimate in Bowes Dairy's listing is 7 days after opening, covered and refrigerated, with a listed range of 0–8°C.
The date and storage instructions on your own pack take priority because they apply to that exact product. General advice on storing cheese fills only the gaps, but it does not extend an earlier pack limit.
Follow the date and storage line on your own pack first, as a general retailer range does not override its refrigeration instructions.